what if?

[doublev2]

Now if vv had stayed on for animalize and Paul had decided vv isn't going to.write much do you think vv would have just played guitar? Could you imagine vv in the heavens on fire video but not being the writer?

[PinkWiz]

There's no way that Vinnie would've stayed during Animalize with little writing credit after he pretty much wrote the entire LIU album. But it's a moot point because if Vinnie hadn't been so rebellious on the LIU tour then Paul and Gene would've probably continued with the LIU formula (Vinnie writing and co-writing all the songs).

I'm thinking that if Vinnie would've worked out then Heaven's On Fire may have never been written (since Paul had to once again seek out Desmond Child once Vinnie was gone).

[erg2]

Learning more and more about Vinnie, I don't think it would've been possible for him to stay in KISS at all...much less in a non-writing capacity.